In which I continue my $6M Comics Shopping Spree
As you may recall, Action Comics #1 (DC, 1938) sold recently for $6M, breaking all previous records for a comic book sold at auction. The sale got me thinking, playing a fun “What if?” game in my head, like you do when you hear about big lottery winners. We all do that, right?
So, let’s say we’ve hit some kind of Brewster’s Millions scenario where we must spend the $6M, and it must be spent on original comic art. Not $1M in comic art and $5M on a really nice house and estate for it all — all $6M of it on comic art.
I will buy stuff I like, not things as “an investment,” and talk about my selections. Art I want to hang on my walls and live with and enjoy. After spending $6M on original art, conservation funding, gallery space, and state-of-the-art storage will be added as a reward, so I don’t have to worry about it as I’m splashing out for big-ticket items and won’t let my museum curator brain get too distracted about planning and worrying about caring for it all longterm. I’ve worked in museums for over twenty years, so I can’t help but think about these things.
Some parameters:
- The budget must be respected — I will only spend $6M and get as close as possible to spending all $6M.
- In the interest of transparency, I will only shop publicly. Gotta show those receipts. No bidding up the next cool thing to $6M and be done. No deals with a wink and a nod to pay $6M for something not worth anywhere near that and split the difference on the back end. Let’s keep this as above board as high-end art buying can be. [cough] (My citation of a sale somewhere *is not* an endorsement to shop there for real.)
- And let’s make the prices recent. No buying Jack Kirby art from a fanzine auction in 1972 and owning every piece by Jack Kirby to cross into private hands. So, let’s say anything purchased must be from any 2020 or more recent public sale. Also, no buying a whole comic shop for $6M.
- And lastly, as curator of the Schulz Museum, it’d be a conflict of interest for me to buy any Peanuts art, so there will be no Charles M. Schulz art on this list, though it’d be a dream come true to own anything by him.
Did I forget anything? Write me and let me. Ok, let’s go!
Winsor McCay
A pioneer of comic strip art, animation, and drawings that will break your brain and make you feel too unworthy to pick up a pencil. However, he was a pioneer of the comic strip form and is widely recognized for his artistic ability, even among art lovers who will turn up their noses at comics. You can read up on him on Wikipedia if you don’t know who he is. Let’s get into some art!
Incredible action in this Little Nemo Sunday page, which is what I always love to see in Nemo strips. The action and the fantasy are all incredible. Doonsbury cartoonist, Garry Trudeau owned this one for an interesting bit of trivia to go along with it as it hangs in my dream collection. It is also one of only a few Winsor McCay Sunday pages sold since 2020. I like this one best because it captures the action I love seeing in his work. I’m also a fan of his draftsmanship, like anyone, but his action is funny and fun to look at, except for the racist bits that he sometimes included, which are gross and a bummer. The price, granted, is more than I have spent on a house in my life, but still — worth it. With $6M to spend, I’m not bargain-hunting!
Again, beautifully drawn — this time with Santa and reindeer and crowds of people we should think of as we head into the holiday season. We see some of McCay’s thinking as an editorial cartoonist. I can really get behind this one. It’d be a treat to hang it on December 23rd and take it down on December 26th like all good Holiday decor.
$6,500 in June 2024 at Swann Galleries
This looks like a sketch, not the finished drawing, which is super impressive on its own. Swann Galleries says it was for one of McCay’s editorial cartoons. Some catastrophic flood has hit Manhattan — another calamity from the mind of Winsor McCay. Nightmares that make you fall out of bed, a sneeze to match a typhoon, and here, with buildings turned topsy-turvy. Again, it is a crazy, fantastic image and frankly, a bargain at the price.
$20,000 in June 2022 at Artcurial
I adore this one. I always love a comic strip about visiting museums. I’ve often thought that would be a fun collection theme — Museums In Comics. I love how McCay outlined the dinosaur and filled in the bones. What it lacks in anatomical correctness, it more than makes up for in skeletal and fossil vibes. Also, there is a hint to his future Gertie the Dinosaur animation! The drawing also *feels* like a fragile clattering problem waiting for the tiniest excuse to fly to bits, which it admirably does in the fifth panel. This is also a seemingly rare strip where a Winsor McCay hero is not being lectured or beaten for their misdeed.
$5,200 in September 2024 from ComicLink Auctions
Speaking of McCay’s work as a pioneer animator, it’d be cool to have a Gertie piece, too, while we’re looking. Several of these have come up for sale in the past couple of years, but I like this pose best for some reason.
$5,148,000 – $274,700 = $4,873,300 remains to spend.
Did you miss Part 1 of this series? Go back here for my first post and watch me spend nearly $1 million on the art of Bill Watterson!
About the Author: Benjamin L. Clark writes and works as a museum curator.